Passion to Profession: How Ben Burrows of The Athletic Reports on the Sports Card Hobby

we are back passion profession shout out ebay for supporting this series fun conversation today i'm excited this is a first in this series of this show which i think you know we've been running for almost two years but i have not spoken with a journalist covering the hobby and that is what we have today i'm joined by ben burrows who currently writes about the industry for the athletic he has had several stops up into this point where he has been involved in covering the space we're gonna dig into kinda his career what he is seeing on the industry side and probably a whole lot more ben welcome man how are you i'm good brad i it's i i'm a big listener of the show i love passion and profession or yeah passion to profession and big hobby jobs listener you know i think we have pros like you out there covering the beat and there's a lot happening in this space whether it's new businesses forming money coming in there's some controversial issues that i know you've been covering but it seems like right now we're in an era where the opportunity to build a career and have some sort of career path or become an entrepreneur and build something yourself seems like the bar is at an all time low so i don't know like maybe we'll open up there like it it feels like there's especially twenty twenty six it's more madness and probably more things for you to cover have popped up than maybe any other year in the industry what what do you say yeah i i mean i would i would pretty much agree with that there's something going on just about every day whether it's something from a trading car manufacturer whether it's something from one of the you know major authenticators like psa or bgs there's there's virtually something going on constantly we've got tons of lawsuits that are are getting thrown out there all the time i'll tell you what i've read so many of these freaking dockets that that i'm on the phone with paul lesko we haven't done it in a while but for the longest time i was on the phone with paul lesko and i'd i tell him like paul just can you read this back to me like i'm five like explain this to me like i'm a child and so i can so i can try to you know explain this to our readers there there's just there's stuff going on all the time new releases i think if you are interested in content creation in any way we're pretty much in a in a golden age of it especially because if if something doesn't happen from one of the manufacturers you can just react to what somebody else said it's it's become you know we we have gone the espn route to embrace debate on a lot of stuff it's it's easier than ever to create content whether or not it's good content to be determined but it's probably yeah easier than ever to to get into this there's there's dawn stop stuff like i mentioned we're gonna get into kinda your background we're gonna get into some of the stops along the way but maybe to follow-up on that i'm i'm very interested when you decided to take this path and cover the sports card industry were you expecting it to be kind of at the level of stories and growth and you know all this all these things that are happening right now like were you expecting that to take place did you think it was gonna be this exciting or were you just kind of interested in it because you were a passionate collector you know it's a so it's a little bit of yes and a little bit of no so you know to give a little bit of background on my story you know i was a traditional newspaper reporter before joining the hobby professionally i've been a lifelong collector thirty plus years at this point i'm thirty six and i think i got started when i was like five and during covid sports stopped so i really didn't have a lot to cover i covered traditional sporting events you know college football college basketball recruiting that all stopped and so i eventually got laid off from my newspaper job and i had to sit there and and think okay where do i go from here i don't i don't wanna stop being a journalist but do i you know what path do i go down what what area of expertise do i go down and i had a conversation with one of my old professors at syracuse and collectibles was not actually technically like the first choice you know we were we were punting around ideas on industries that we thought were expanding that didn't have good journalism yet and the industries that we thought about were you know at the at the at this time sports betting was like just really starting to ramp up you know gambling had been legalized in a lot of states a lot of these gambling companies were looking for former sports reporters to come in because they looked at it as kind of like a you know an easy crossover collectibles was expanding so that made sense i actually looked at esports quite a bit i'm a big esports fan i'm a big gamer and there's just not a lot of journal really good journalism in the esports space and so i actually there there was a time where i thought i was gonna move to las vegas and work for a gambling company like we were you know my partner at the time and i you know she wasn't super thrilled but we were we were looking at apartments in las vegas so we thought that that was gonna happen ended up not happening then i get into the hobby professionally and i thought that there was like i i definitely thought that there was a high ceiling for it i did not expect it to expand as quickly as it did and it's expanded into so many different areas where you know i was used to just like going to games or calling up recruits and and you know my my day to day was pretty like relatively linear you know working in newspapers here i've had to focus on i've never read as many lawsuits i've never done you know there's the the hobby has expanded where you know you have to report on lawsuits there's like the business side of it there's like the ethics side of it there's the manufacturing side of it there's all these different paths that i just never expected to come into play and i really just thought i was gonna talk about you know whether or not cards were cool you know whether or not they were valuable or you know where where they could go from a from a roi standpoint and so part of me thought that there could be expansion whether or not it would become what i you know what we experience now where i very much feel like it could be the next like fantasy football did not did not quite expect it to to get there let alone like this quickly so you mentioned you went to syracuse and i think when a lot of people hear syracuse they think of you know producing some of the best you know media talent journalists people covering a lot of different industries i guess like through that experience of like you wanting to be a journalist going to syracuse and kinda figuring out you talked about your path but figuring it out like what do you think it says now about this sports card industry in this space that somebody who has gone through the schooling you have and has the experience that you have is now covering the industry and i i read a lot of stuff i pay attention and there's there's not a lot of other ben burrows out there right now but to me it feels like when i can open up the athletic app and i can click the collectibles tab and see like professional articles and work being done and sourcing the right people and digging into data like it feels like to me that it gives me confidence as a builder in the space because it's like feels like it's becoming more professionalized and now we have journalists covering the space so i don't know like it feels like we've graduated this year and probably some of the work that you're presenting to people who have not thought about cards from this perspective have helped but like how do you think about your role in that graduation from like it being kind of like a industry that has a certain perception that we've had growing up in the nineties and two thousands to kinda where we're at today yeah well i think my my first thought on that is that our hobby just isn't as niche as it it used to be you know when my mom is texting me about pokemon cards or just like random stories that she sees on apple news i think we have we have broken containment right and my mom has obviously always been involved in in the collecting space to some extent but you know god love her susan is not super locked in to to this industry but when when when she is seeing stuff and is like hey have you seen this you know every now and then i'm like mom i wrote the story like but read the byline but i think it's it's definitely elevated and i think well one i think it's it's a good marker for the industry to see major organizations like the athletic is owned by the new york times it's it's a good thing for the hobby i think objectively if the new york times thinks that this space is so significant that it's worth covering and one i mean i've always been a big believer that any industry deserves to have good journalism you know if there are you know we we we often look at politics or major professional sports as what people largely follow but there's great journalism for movies and tv there's you know great journalists that cover food i mean there's great fashion journalists there's there's all of these different categories if there are trade publications for like knitting and trains and photography why why couldn't there be something like that for the hobby like our hobby you know we kinda selfishly adopted the word the hobby there are other hobbies that exist but we have we have kinda commandeered that which i'm i'm okay with but you know we're it's it's a multibillion dollar per month industry at this point i think it's a good thing that it's expanded this way and i think it's a really good thing that we're seeing companies like the new york times get involved with it because it helps legitimize the space but it also helps bring well this is something that we're hope we're doing an added lever level of transparency to a category that i think desperately needs it yeah i want to hit on that and i wanna hit on first i want you to help the listener understand not i don't want you to like like make this sound like this is like you and you're doing this work you're helping contribute to it but like the fact that you have an outlet that is owned by new york times that is covering the space i think is significant i think we when we consume content so much of it comes from a creator perspective it comes from like apps like instagram platforms like youtube and you know it can just be someone just turning on a microphone and talking about something and sharing information and we're in this era where like accurate information is like critical and like we get online and we don't know what to see and believe so i want you to maybe share some perspective on like how outlets like the athletic and new york times wanting to cover this space how that really impacts the industry from a legitimacy perspective and then also like like how do you think about that because we know like we're not naive there's a lot of bad actors and yeah nefarious things going on so like how do you think about your role in helping kind of share those stories and making people aware of what they might not be seeing but what is actually going on right now in the space yeah well i think it's critical for us as journalists to abide by you know very specific tenants and i think that is something that is critical for people that might not understand the dynamic between a content creator and a journalist and there's nothing i wanna full transparency i don't think there's anything wrong with being a content creator but the the standard that we have for the athletic and the new york times and and traditional journalists is much higher for how we disseminate information and i also think that that's a key thing you know people have asked me well like what are your you know what's your goal as a creator it's not to be famous it's not to make a ton of money my key objective is to disseminate the news and you know it it comes from an area of neutrality you know unless i'm specifically offering up an opinion in which i will preface this by saying like hey this is my opinion here that's acceptable but you know we are coming at it from a neutral standpoint we are trying to disseminate the news as it's happening in the most accurately way possible with as little spin as possible it's it's possible to provide analysis and potential impact but you know we have to do things from a neutral standpoint at a super high level people should understand that they can trust what we report because our standards are much much higher than you know the traditional creator in in terms of well you you you're not gonna hear us saying oh well this is the rumor i hear rumors all the time man like i'll tell you i i've i can write a book about all the rumors but the it's whether or not it's reportable is is a completely different thing right and so the standard is much different and we're also trying to provide a certain amount of transparency to the processes that that we see from these companies and through that we hopefully hold them accountable you know and it's it's you know when a when a trading card manufacturer makes a mistake or a grading company makes a mistake it's not our role to like beat them over the head it's our role to disseminate the news and then the reader the listener the consumer can decide whether or not they get to beat them over the head like that's not our role our role is to simply catalog what has happened and through that hopefully people understand that we're doing at a at a really high level and we're very trustworthy but through that you know the the good things are that there's gonna be additional transparency there's gonna be additional accountability and through transparency and accountability it hopefully improves this space you know for the for the better i think accountability is a a fun and interesting topic and some individuals might not like the fact that that is a focus of yours as a journalist yeah maybe from this perspective of there have been many people many companies have who have done things the way they've done things for years and have made a lot of money and have been a lot really successful and have not had to be accountable for maybe missteps or things along the way or maybe they've said okay i'm gonna be accountable where i'll just disappear for a couple months and then i'll come back like nothing ever happened like what have you observed just on the accountability front just across the industry do you find that the the accountability and of maybe some missteps and bad acting has improved is it gotten worse like how are you viewing it from your seat as a journalist covering the the industry at the athletic i think the accountability and the transparency has gotten marginally better and i will couch that a little bit with it has gone from completely horrific to kind of just pretty bad frankly and this this is this has been one of the biggest challenges in the space i thought reporting on this category was gonna be a lot easier than it has been you know one of one of the one of the other guys on the vertical larry holder would agree with this you know he covered the nfl and the new orleans saints for like twenty years before covering collectibles and he and i both agree and i covered major college football and college basketball it is way more difficult to interact with the with the people and the companies in this space than it was professional and major college sports and like that and and from from the standpoint of you know like if i need to get to a player you know you can reach out to them directly sometimes or there's like a you know an sid that you can reach out to or you know there there are comms people that work for these teams i'll tell you right now it it's been way easier to work with the atlanta i'm based here in atlanta working with the atlanta braves which is a publicly traded company has been significantly easier than working with some of the major companies in in the space and it's i think part of it is there was no accountability for a long time there was no major journalistic outlet or you know there there have been some some companies like sports collectors daily and sports collectors digest that that have done some really good stuff you know the old beckett magazines that have attempted to do stuff you know before the athletics so you know this isn't completely new i don't think anybody has done it to this scale and to the quality but i think a lot of the companies just didn't expect to have to provide any transparency at all there was not a professional journalist calling them to say hey you guys lost a whole bunch of cards outside your you know your grading facility what the heck happened to them no one was gonna call them about that and so it's been frankly pretty difficult to get some of that information now where we're you know we're calling these companies and saying hey like you you made a huge mistake how did that happen and they're just like it happens you know or they don't you know they don't respond at all or you know they they just don't think that they have a lot of responsibility to the community to describe what their process was what they what they're doing to fix it what went wrong so it has marginally improved but again it's gone from just completely horrific to just like pretty bad and you know i won't i won't call them out specifically there there are some companies that are better than others and there are some that just like are outright combative to get virtually anything and i'm sure some of them are listening and if you think that it's you it's it probably is you like i'll just i'll be forthright with that right now if you think that you are combative with me and some of my colleagues like it's probable that's probably the case and and there's a lot of room for improvement i i think about this and it's an observation i make in this space and as someone who kind of i built my career on the back of you know marketing communications helping making sure the companies i was working for we were saying this the right thing and getting out in front of things and mistakes that we made and one of the observations i've made since working in this space is that there's this thought process that when something goes wrong the best thing to do is not say anything at all right and just act like it'll eventually go away and i see it constantly and again we're not gonna point any fingers or call anybody out but i i i i see it happening in with companies across the space and i'm like i'm not saying what how i would handle this would be would be the right way but i think the way a lot of people would recommend you're handling the situation is probably not the best way now i think about someone in your role and you're giving individuals the opportunity to get out in front of the story i would imagine getting a comment trying to figure out what actually happened and people instead decide to be combative or people maybe don't answer your emails or don't respond to your texts or calls like why do you think that is that's happening why do you think that's the default now as opposed to someone you know holding themselves accountable and making me themselves a little vulnerable and admitting their fault like why do you think it's that way right now so i think it's a combination of two things one i think it's it's just a a disagreement in philosophy you know there because because i know that this isn't the case you know everywhere i have a really good friend that might end up listening to this that is a a pr professional that specifically works with like crisis and i go to him often for these things i'm like you know if you were doing something like this and he works with national brands like huge massive brands like bigger brands that are bigger than fanatics he has worked with you know professional teams major companies that are extremely large and i go to him and i'm like how would you approach this and it's almost always i think they fumbled this one this is what i would have done differently like these are the areas where they could have been more transparent and instead they punted it because they their philosophy is never admit wrongdoing never admit defeat and one i think like i think that that's a poor philosophy decision because i think collectors the reasonable collectors will understand that mistakes happen at scale sometimes the logistics behind what some of these companies are doing is absolutely insane i i think ninety nine percent of hobbyists have no clue the scale and the the complexity of of the logistics that that goes into making a trading card set or grading cards at scale or any of these things it is so unbelievably complicated and i think collectors would just like companies to be honest and forthright about what potentially went wrong they they they want to be treated like adults in the room they want companies to say hey we messed this up this is this is how we're one going to make you whole or make this thing right and then these are the steps that we're gonna take to make sure that this hopefully doesn't happen again and the other factor i think is immaturity in the space and i don't mean that in the sense of people are acting like children i mean in the sense that a lot of these companies don't even have internal communication teams you know a company like fanatics has like three full time people on just collectibles right you know collectors capital c collectors just to be clear has a comms team and has people that that are working with each you know each of its brands there are some companies that use external agencies and so they're not even prepared if a professional journalist comes to them and is asking serious questions we're sort of having to go through a proxy and like that that's not abnormal but when you when you're having to go through a third party agency there's often a communication disconnect because those people may not be professionally trained to understand collectibles so then they might not be able to go to their you know their vendor and say hey like this message doesn't quite land the way that i think the hobby might want it to you know here's how we adjust it's just gonna be relaying that message and if the message is broken from the beginning they don't know how to fix it and so i think it's just right now it's a combination of unfortunate disagreements and philosophy and there are some companies that i think simply were not prepared for the moment when the hobby right now is exploding into a full fledged multibillion dollar industry and a lot of these companies that were you know wanted to treat themselves as mom and pop shops they were not ready for the moment how do you think and i i'm not trying to put yourself in their shoes but naturally like you're closer to this than anybody probably listening i think about this from the perspective of look at the outlet mhmm we all everybody in the country and probably the better part of the world knows about the new york times people who love sports know that times acquired the athletic and i i'm i told you when we were on a call i'm a subscriber to the athletic i love the athletic i just think it's a great publication and i understand how many people that that publication reaches so i just can't understand even when there's a misstep or something that you're asking somebody to comment on why they wouldn't have a conversation to try to give you a quote on the story when down the road they might be launching something new or have a new product that you at the athletic who's got all of these eyeballs and all of these subscribers can talk about like is it just they don't people can't see the the big picture in this space and everyone's worried about the right now as as opposed to the long road or something else yeah so that that's a really interesting observation and i'll tell you this i think probably it's it's mostly on my front but when i have conversations with my editor brooks peck who is absolutely phenomenal one of the most influential people in our space right now that doesn't get enough credit when brooks and i are talking about basically this exact same thing we often say like the the most common phrase is you can't help people that don't wanna be helped and like our job is not necessarily to help these companies but it can be mutually beneficial like you being more transparent as a company is mutually beneficial often and so we are constantly met with instances where it would be extremely helpful to be more transparent and you know sometimes they'll they'll explain like i've had several of these conversations recently where something has happened and they're willing to talk to me off the record to basically like you know it's it's often like a chance to save face and hope that we don't like bludgeon them which again is like not our role our role is not to intentionally publicly bludgeon anyone it's to disseminate the news and then the community gets to decide what their own sentiment is and i'll give you an interesting anecdote for like why i think this happens like again some of it pulls back to a difference in philosophy and a lot of it is like the c suite may decide that they just you know mums the word which is annoying but fine it's their decision i had an interesting conversation several years ago with one of the largest companies in in the space and i won't i won't put them on blast because it it would it's it's gonna be a very unpopular anecdote here and i remember talking to them about a way to cover their business and how they could be more helpful and their response was basically in spirit our product is kind of like toilet paper like you just kinda like if you know you need it you need it there's like a couple brands out there and we really don't need to advertise you know we sort of our business is running at capacity we really don't need help to sell our product in any way like it it is doing super well it's doing well it was already doing well covid happened the industry has exploded we're doing better than ever you know thanks but no thanks and that that was the the suggested coverage was sort of additional transparency you know sort of trying to you know tell more stories about how the product is created and and the logistics behind it and and i remember being stunned because i i couldn't understand why a a company in this category would view itself as we don't really need to advertise we don't need to reach more people like we're just good and so there's there's a little bit there was a little bit of an ego there on on that side but i was completely stunned and so it's you know i that's definitely not the case for everyone i promise you know there are a lot of companies that we work with or try to work with that are like hey we would like to talk about this but you know the overlords have said no you know the c suite overlords have said no we just can't we this isn't my call but you know we're we're told we can't say anything so it's not everyone but there are again i think some companies that wanted to operate as mom and pop shops that were not ready for this moment and did not see and probably still don't see that news coverage can be helpful you know it doesn't always have to be us bludgeoning you again that's not the objective here but disseminating the news can be helpful and providing transparency builds customer goodwill and so you know even if you take a little you know some lumps it it can be overall positive because collectors just wanna be treated like adults in the room right how much of the withholding of information or no commenting or off the record stuff how much of that do you think is based on how competitive the landscape has become especially across a lot of different pockets it feels like the competition and what people are launching what people don't wanna talk about it feels like just from my seat as someone who runs weekly content where i'm talking with different industry professionals especially this year it feels like man this is feels like a a more competitive environment from an industry perspective than ever before mhmm i i think that plays i i don't know that i would say like a significant role but it's not insignificant by any means i think companies are worried about potential disruption i i almost think some of these companies are more worried about someone that is isn't even on their radar yet with the amount of money that is coming into the space you know i just don't think in in you know from like a grading perspective people also also ask me all the time like you know there's such a big delta between like psa and everybody else and including like the the other collectors brands you know the delta between psa and cgc is is so big how does that gap close and my answer is often it closes when psa decides it can close from like a logistical standpoint the delta is just massive they're like i don't know that if as long as psa wants it to remain big i don't think it's catchable but i think the other the the only other factor is like the industry has a new competitor that doesn't even exist yet we don't know a name for it the company doesn't exist in any way and it comes in and turns the industry on its head and that's where i think companies get a little bit worried and that's not to like necessarily say that psa is super worried about this you know i'm i'm they're smart people sir i'm sure they're they are to some extent but i think we're seeing so much money poured into the space now that who's to say that ten years from now or twenty years from now whenever the fanatics deals are up the exclusive deals are up that a new company hasn't come in who who's to say that the leagues themselves don't say you know what what if we just don't have to deal with you at all what if we build our own you know printing press outside dallas or maybe we acquire the one that that you guys did you know let's let's just cut the middleman out and forget all the logistics i think that's what a lot of companies worry about is right now more than ever i think you're more likely to be blindsided by a competitor you didn't even know existed yet so it it it i i wouldn't say it's like a crazy thing but it's it's not insignificant by any means whether or not people wanna wanna divulge some of that info and frankly i laugh at it sometimes because i have very similar conversations with some of these companies and they're talking about the same stuff like they're doing the same stuff yeah like i don't want this secret to come out and i'm like i'm not gonna you know trade that info but in my head i'm like i don't know how to tell you this buddy but like the ship has sailed on that concept like i you know it's you you don't actually have a secret good luck but yeah that's a that not a secret at all that's amazing i i wanna hear from you about some of these stories that you've covered this year but i wanna make sure that listeners understand that you didn't just like graduate from syracuse and end up covering collectibles at the athletic you had a few stops along the way sports card investor sports sports illustrated working for collect and now you're at the athletic maybe talk about some of those experiences and kinda how they helped shape you into the type of journalist you're you are today covering the beat at the athletic yeah so i mean the my my time in collectibles has been pretty extensive at this point but it still hasn't even matched my time we're getting close to it matching my time as just a traditional newspaper journalist and so like my first my first job out of out of college with was with the harrisburg patriot news i'm originally from pennsylvania it's the penn state bible i worked with pulitzer prize winners like i worked with some of the greatest journalist journalists in the entire world like those are some of the people that i got to learn from and then i went to the syracuse post standard again some of the best journalists in the entire world work at that newspaper and when covid happened that obviously changed my calculus but i had this unbelievable foundation of getting to work with these unbelievable journalists that were covering a different category and then i get into the hobby professionally so i'm sitting there trying to think you know what the heck am i gonna do and jeff wilson you know had established sports card investor and was sort of going on like a hiring spree really this is like when the company sort of exploded i think i was within like the first ten or twelve employees at that company like just in a a tiny office well i i wouldn't say tiny but you know our desks are all right next to each other and you know jeff is just sitting he doesn't even have his own office he's just sitting at a at a desk in the open office you know i could i could throw a a paper airplane at his face if i wanted to you know ten feet away he's just a a regular guy in there but he was looking for like a professional journalist to come in and and sort of help elevate the content that they were doing at the time and he actually ended up hiring he had one opening and he actually ended up hiring both of us and so he hired me and he hired another guy who is now the managing editor for forbes travel so jeff kinda has a knack for hiring some some good folks hopefully we'll we'll we'll see if people still like me after this conversation but you know sci was really interesting because it it's more of like an entertainment brand than a news brand and i went into that thinking this isn't gonna be traditional journalism but it doesn't mean that we can't still apply like the tenants of of journalism like some you know the the standards that we wanna see and that doesn't mean that we don't make mistakes but sci was like this you know exploding into this massive entertainment brand and then i was there for i think like two and a half years or so and i i loved working there and i had long told them i won't leave unless one of two companies calls the athletic or sports illustrated and bad news is sports illustrated called and wanted to launch collectibles they had they had started to do research they had no clue that they were even like a a popular brand in the hobby they were like executives from si that had gone to the national sports collectors convention in chicago one year and were like people collect this stuff like we had no idea that we're a big brand in the space maybe we should actually cover it and so from there i became the first collectibles editor in the history of sports illustrated was a a dream job that i would have never even considered being possible right would have you know growing up you you maybe want if you wanna be a journalist you wanna work for sports illustrated if you're into sports but i would have never thought that trading cards would be you know a thing unfortunately that was also you know like my first day we had a meeting with like new ownership and so like logistically the company was going through a transition with new ownership and new leadership and got very messy and i just decided it it wasn't like a good fit anymore took an off ramp to collect which you know has since pivoted away from journalism but like we really wanted to do like hardcore trading card journalism and collectibles journalism like that was the thesis of the company and it has since transitioned to you know more consulting and and advising and from there i i was there for about i think a little less than two years and then now i'm completely freelance the majority of my work is with the athletic and i've sort of like found my way back to just traditional journalism but yeah it's been it's been i've been working in the space now professionally for almost like five or six years and we're getting close to matching my newspaper career and so i hope people know that like if there's any takeaway from this it's i've sort of been around the block in this space but you know it's it wasn't just me deciding to write stories about the about the hobby which is okay you can you can start that way but i had a really significant foundation in journalism you know before i ever got to the space and and that has just been instrumental into actually creating the content that i do because my skill set i think is just vastly different than the overwhelming majority of of people in the space and there should be diversity in in skill set but i hope people know that i think mine's a little bit different i wanna hit on that because you said something when you're talking about your run working in newspapers that you've worked with some of the best of the best and you learn from people who were covering categories outside of yours and you you know take that experience and you keep applying it to kinda new opportunities one of the things i'm seeing a lot of in the space right now is it feels like there's a lot of people coming from outside of the industry into the industry working for these companies are starting their own thing which i think is good i think new ideas new innovation new skill sets help this industry grow and take shape and help it sustain i wanna get kinda your perspective on that topic and just some of the observations you've seen is this something that is is happening at a on a regular pace right now where people are deciding to place their career bets on the hobby i'm just curious through your your stories and conversations what you're saying yeah i do and i think so i think it's happening in two areas as well like i think we're seeing a lot of people from like a content creation standpoint getting into the hobby and i think we're seeing you know from like a you know people wanting to start card shops and and card related businesses and unless you grew up working at a card shop like i think this is an industry that you kind of have to transition into right and i think it's really valuable like i'm a big fan of taking these interesting skill sets and bringing them into the hobby because i think the hobby has also been a little bit of a hive mind for a really long time and i think it's really good to get diversity of thought into the space and i also think you know it's it's sort of like an inside baseball thing but a really interesting observation that i've seen at like the corporate level and this sort of validates this also sort of validates how the hobby has grown so significantly in recent years is that you can look at a company like fanatics and if you look at you know their leadership you do sort of have guys that have been in the hobby for twenty years or something like that or are old upper deck folks or tops folks or panini folks but when they're going to hire somebody for marketing they're like how do we get somebody from nike or you know somebody from red bull or somebody from netflix you know collectors capital c collectors psa's parent company they just hired a new head of communications he came from nike and microsoft before that and so we're seeing a massive influx of non hobby folks coming into the space and one like i think it's important that they're still working with people with really strong hobby foundations but i think the hobby is being met with issues that it didn't expect before right you know and a good like a good example of that could be you know collectors of the brand with psa and beckett and sgc they've been going through they've either been going through change right now or they have had issues that have popped up recently you know their new head of comms has has worked with crisis before and so we're seeing like these companies specifically recruit for specific skill sets that might not have existed in the hobby before because the hobby wasn't experiencing these issues before and it's much easier to go and find somebody with that expertise in a different like i think a lot of companies right now are viewing it as it's easier for us to find somebody with crisis expertise and then teach them about trading cards to have a working knowledge then to try to force the trading card guy into understanding how to operate a crisis for a billion dollar company at a national scale you know i think one of those skill sets is a little is a little easier to teach than the other and so yeah i think we're seeing an influx of of people at the corporate level and the and the card shop level and i i think it's i think it's objectively a really good thing which profile is easier for you to communicate with individual who has domain knowledge and experience of this industry or the outsider coming in who's got a specific skill set based that they've gained in another industry and they're coming in i think right now it's definitely like the hobby domain person usually because i'm able to create a strong connection with them immediately like even before we have to talk about business we can just chitchat about what they collect or why they collect you know and and we build this this personal foundation that sort of makes performing the business side of things a little bit easier you know i think with the professionals coming in the challenge they they often want to work with us on different things but where the challenge can come is the hobby is just so nuanced and frankly you know like i fear for some of the folks that are coming into it without a huge background because it's so nuanced i think the hobby is naturally pessimistic to a certain extent is a little combative to a certain extent and because of that nuance they may not understand why something is important why a very specific detail is important and i can sit here and bang the drum of like hey this is it this may seem really small to you but this really matters for the community and that like that connection might might just not get made unfortunately and it's it's a little bit of a catch twenty two so i wanna get into some story specific stuff you've covered this year and the one of the stories that you published let me look it was june tenth twenty twenty six and it the headline is a hundred million revolute in revenues for sports card sellers inside the race to own the live selling market that is a attention grabbing number at the top if you look read the article there was a mention about the growth according to emarketer what social commerce eighty seven billion dollar business not just in the hobby but just across all industries and then when i'm reading the article there it it you disclose that there are businesses in this space live selling that are a hundred million dollar businesses which is absolutely insane yeah so i want you to kinda help us understand like walk us through like why that was a story you covered like what you learned and kind of what you were looking to accomplish by dedicating your time to a story like that and putting it out there on the athletic yeah so like the the genesis of that story actually came from we started to see you know we're we're obviously we try to be in tune with you know the the major breaking platforms you know the live selling platforms you know and so we largely look at whatnot and fanatics collect as that we started to notice that ebay was like siphoning off some of these major players that had been largely exclusive or semi exclusive to some of these platforms and you know ebay is this legacy brand that was slow to adopt live selling compared to you know whatnot is considered the first mover from a trading card perspective you know fanatics finesse collect came in and has a smaller platform but obviously has a direct connection with one of the trading card manufacturers so that gives it like an inherent advantage in in some way or so we thought and so we saw that and we're like well has the hobby like has this space gotten so valuable now that these companies feel the need to poach talent from one another like quote unquote talent from one another because that's their like if you wanna i'm not gonna argue with people if they're like ah breakers aren't you know you know you shouldn't call them talent or like athletes or anything like that i don't really care about that but like that's how they're being viewed by these these live selling platforms it's like they they are these individuals or these companies that are platforms it's like they they are these individuals or these companies that are providing a very valuable service and they want to pull them over and so we we thought that that was interesting and we sort of wanted to explore the dynamic between why these companies are fighting over these smaller brands and like their audiences which are spending tens of millions if not hundreds of millions of dollars which the way that i understand it is i think there's there's like maybe upwards of like ten of some of these live selling companies that are probably gonna do like a hundred million dollars in in in revenue this year and there's a few that have been described to me as doing upwards of potentially four hundred million dollars in revenue and like they're just like we look at them as sort of like small slices of the hobby but the slice isn't small anymore and so the goal there was you know we just observed an interesting phenomenon that was happening and we're like well let's try to understand why let's try to tell the story of why this is happening and let's try to quantify you know anecdotally what the scale of this might be and that's that's a question that we are constantly trying to answer because no one people are always throwing out these numbers of like the the hobby is is this big you know it's x billion dollars and i i'm gonna be honest i don't think we have any freaking clue how big the hobby is i don't think anyone has actually come close to quantifying it the way that it should be done because of private sales and stuff that doesn't get you know get publicly reported to the irs and like i think when when people are throwing numbers out there you know like i think there is there is one that got i think there was a i think bank of america just threw out a number that was like two billion dollars for live selling i think that's way low mhmm like i i don't think that's even closely comprehending how much like that's that's ten companies like that's ten live selling breakers across whatnot fanatics live in ebay are doing two billion dollars a year what are we talking about you know and there's there's hundreds of of other companies that are contributing to it and so you know the genesis really was we just observe something interesting and wanted to under better understand why it was happening and from there we we talked to people and we're like okay like if you're if you're selling on whatnot what motivates you to go to ebay like what motivates you to change your business model to go to one of these other companies what are they offering you you know and one of the interesting anecdotes that came out of that was everybody sort of assumed that fanatics would put its thumb on the scale for this i think a lot of people were like well they're you know they're gonna cut allocation if you if you don't break on fanatics live and a lot of the folks that i talked to were like that hasn't really happened to us at all you know they would like us to operate on fanatics live but you know it's it's better for them to keep giving us all of this allocation because they wanna sell trading cards than to cut back and force us to go to like a platform that for us isn't performing as well as one of the others and so it was just an interesting dynamic that we often ask like is there an interesting question here that the hobby would would be happy to know more about and has it been explored before you know has anybody attempted to do this before because i think that's a critical thing that we think about is are we the only ones capable of doing this story and if the answer is yes then that that's a a significant motivator that like we should try to do this and maybe it doesn't work out i've you know some stuff sort of dies on the vine you know or a story gets killed but you know that that was sort of the genesis of that is just trying to trying to answer an interesting question that and hopefully come up with anecdotes that no one had ever told before which i think we like somewhat accomplished accomplished i talk with enough individuals who own businesses who are participating in live selling to know that all of them want more talent to be in front of the camera more experienced talent and without a shadow of a doubt is the number one role is breaking and being very good and having a personality so it maps back to kind of just the impact of live commerce in the area of focus for so many businesses in this space what has been maybe like your favorite thing to cover this year like when you think back to twenty twenty six like what's a story what's something that like you've gotten really excited about something really exciting can i go back further than twenty twenty six yeah go for it so usually so the things that i get most excited about honestly are usually the things that frustrate companies the most where they're they're like man like this is so annoying that you went through the process to do this and i think in recent years the thing that i've been most excited to like present was because it was such an an annoying process is at this point we all know about like the rookie debut patches and we have obviously seen some of the attachments of these these items to jerseys fail and this was back when i was working at collect and everyone was watching for the cooper flagg rookie debut patch and so we know for baseball that these these items are attached to the jerseys and then removed after the game so we're watching the mavericks game and we see cooper flagg obviously wearing the patch in the first half everyone is super excited to see it they think it's gonna sell for millions of dollars which he eventually did but a red flag went up when in the second half he comes back out and he's got the patch on again and my colleague at collect will stern and i were like that doesn't seem right because guys are wearing multiple jerseys for these games at this point you know the for those unfamiliar the nba has a deal with sotheby's to sell these jerseys so like when guys are making their debuts one of the jerseys has to contractually be delivered to sotheby's to be auctioned off and if the player wants to own one of the debut jerseys they have to wear multiple and so a lot of these guys swap them at halftime so if the jersey got swapped at halftime it was okay well is there a second debut patch did they remove it and then reattach it to the jersey and then the next day because then that impacts like well if sotheby's is gonna sell it that impacts the price of of that debut jersey you know we know like victor wominayama wore wore multiple like a lot of these guys usually wear at least two and for somebody like cooper flagg we assume that they're probably gonna wear three so that like the team can maybe have one cooper can have one and then sotheby's gets its you know several million dollars for for this jersey and so the next day will and i spent hours looking at getty images to photo match the jerseys to definitively say that the jersey he wore in the first half was not the jersey that he wore in the second half and we spent hours going through these these high res images to eventually find a knot in like one of the numbers on the front of his jersey there's like a knot in i forget was he like number i forget what his number is but we we found a knot in one of one of the numbers to be able to definitively say the this is different like this is definitively a different jersey so then we go to fanatics and we're like what happened here you know was it the debut patch got removed and then put on the new jersey or are there now multiple debut patches and fanatics was like this is so annoying that you and like you spent the time to do this you guys are act actually psychotic and then they had to come out and say yes so he wore multiple debut patches for this game the additional ones are you know have been destroyed and then the first one that he wore will be put in the card and so that like that's the stuff that i often get most excited about is doing the stuff that a company doesn't expect you to actually do like going far enough to do what what you would expect to do and then i think like obviously you know the the psa fedex story this year has been particularly interesting when that first started to leak out i was over the over that first weekend i was out of town visiting family in charlotte and so i like sorta kept a little bit of an eye on it and then when i got back on that monday i drove back from charlotte to atlanta and was very surprised that no one had called the cops yet and so that's that's what i did i was like i'm just gonna i'm just gonna freaking call the cops see what the police have to say about this there's i've seen a thousand videos about this like quote unquote psa heist or something did nobody ask an adult about about this and it turns out no one did and so like that that was that was another example not not quite as going as far as like the cooper flag stuff that took like hours and hours of ex like staring at getty images with will but you know that was one where i don't think psa had expected anyone to call the police mhmm you know or you know maybe they did but no one had yet and that was just like i i just took it like one little step further than everybody else is willing to go which i've now told people like if you're just like a regular person please don't call the police and ask them about this stuff but if you're a member of the media that's like an interesting an interesting addition to the tool toolkit that you can do we can just actually call the cops and ask them what happened and they will they will tell you usually the best journalists are often the best detectives so i love all of that insight and we gotta get out of here but before i let you go ben we're moving into twenty twenty seven here it'll be here before we know it what is on your mind like what is your area of focus or is there anything any takeaway you can give listeners of just like something that is interesting you that either you're thinking about covering or potentially will be a topic you'll wanna cover regarding kind of what's happening across the sports card industry there's there's kind of a few you know i'm really interested in how some of these trading card manufacturers evolve you know fanatics has really grabbed a lot of the licenses the key licenses and i'm still really interested to see how panini steps up to the plate and tries to really compete i think they've been a little sleepy since since losing the nba license and the nfl license these things take time to build out like when a when a company acquires a new license there's usually like like for perspective a typical trading card set usually takes between twelve and eighteen months from like you know first being developed like storyboarded to actually like hitting shelves so it takes time but i'm really interested to see if panini is able to actually compete with fanatics without traditional licenses i'm really curious to see if one of the non capital c collectors grading companies is able to take a step forward cgc has has really expanded but logistically it's really hard to hire people they're they're sort of just like a bottleneck there for graders to to get trained so that's always difficult does tag improve its ai and machine learning to better compete with the with the major four trading card authenticators and i'm also really interested to see where some of the money that we're seeing pour into the hobby is coming from we're seeing a lot of investment types getting into the space you know people can debate whether or not you know it's a good or a bad thing i'm still up in the air on whether or not it's good or bad you know i think it's a nuanced question but i'm really interested to see if that continues you know if there are more kevin o'leary types that get into the space if there are more companies that decide that this space is so significant and has so much velocity that it's worth investing heavily in because i i still think to call back to one of your earlier questions i think the the industry is really ripe for disruption and so i think there's probably a company out there that we don't even know exists yet might not you know might not even be thought of yet that in twenty twenty seven could come in like a wrecking ball and flip a a ton of stuff up you know on its head those are those are the things that i'm i think will be really interesting to see in twenty twenty seven this was a fascinating conversation you can check out ben's work at the athletic we gotta do this again man i got like a hundred more questions i wanna answer you so rask you so we we gotta do it again down the road yeah happy to happy to thanks for having me my friend

Stacking Slabs